Dave Portnoy says Ohio State, Ryan Day saw him as a 'major, major headache' on 'Big Noon Kickoff'

Dave Portnoy fired back Friday, taking to social media to pre-empt a report from The Athletic’s Andrew Marchand that he would no longer appear on FS1’s *Big Noon Kickoff*.
“Ohio State and Ryan Day b*tched and moaned to the Big 10 and threatened Fox till they had no choice,” Portnoy wrote.
“Juice wasnt worth the squeeze [and] frankly I dont blame them. Huge dollars at stake and you have Cryin Ryan throwing temper tantrums [and] making threats every few days on something I said. I always knew Ryan Day was soft but holy sh*t even I didnt realize he was this soft.”
Portnoy’s claims about Day’s threats are his own allegations, not independently confirmed. Marchand’s report, however, essentially confirmed that Ohio State-related concerns were part of the decision to cut ties with the Barstool Sports founder.

Portnoy began appearing on the show last season as part of a Fox Sports-Barstool partnership, but his role had been limited because several Big Ten schools, especially Ohio State, raised concerns. The abrupt split follows years of escalating friction between Portnoy and the Buckeyes’ head coach.
THE FOX SPLIT
Marchand essentially confirmed that Ohio State-related concerns were part of the decision, but he stopped short of pinning the split on any single incident. “As for the abrupt timing of the decision, those sources said there was no smoking gun other than that the constant challenge of trying to unite Fox Sports’ more traditional show with Barstool’s persona proved unsustainable,” Marchand wrote.
The specific reasons for the abrupt timing are not fully confirmed. Marchand’s sources pointed to a broader clash of cultures rather than one decisive blow.

Marchand also noted that Portnoy, a Michigan alum and booster, has faced disputes over his presence at Ohio State home games, with reports last year saying he was banned from being in the stadium. Portnoy has previously been banned from doing the final hour of the show in Big Ten stadiums, something he has blamed on Ohio State.
Portnoy started appearing on the show last season as part of a Fox Sports-Barstool Sports partnership, but his role had been limited because several Big Ten schools, especially Ohio State, raised concerns. The arrangement was never seamless, and the friction only grew as Portnoy’s history with Day and the Buckeyes piled up.
THE BACKSTORY
None of this happened in a vacuum. In 2023, Portnoy said Ryan Day would be suspended because he had been “caught cheating and for far worse” than anything Jim Harbaugh did, per awfulannouncing.com. Nothing ever came of that prediction.

Then, in 2025, Portnoy escalated. He claimed he knew of an “Ohio State mole” who stole data and illegally recorded Conor Stalions, the central figure in the Michigan sign-stealing scandal, according to awfulannouncing.com. Portnoy also amplified rumors suggesting that Day hired his own brother’s private investigation firm to look into Michigan during that scandal.
No proof ever showed that anyone affiliated with Ohio State was involved in any of that, per awfulannouncing.com. Portnoy’s claims about the “Ohio State mole” and Day’s alleged involvement remain unproven.
The accusations fit a pattern of open warfare between Portnoy, a Michigan alum and booster, and the Buckeyes’ head coach. Each new claim deepened the friction that ultimately made Portnoy’s presence on “Big Noon Kickoff” untenable for Fox Sports and the Big Ten.
Portnoy’s history with Day was never just about game-day antics or barstool bravado. It was personal, public and relentless — and the past two years only sharpened the edge.

THE REACTION
Portnoy took his case to Front Office Sports on Monday, sitting down with Ryan Glasspiegel to offer further details on how the situation fell apart, per awfulannouncing.com. The full content of that interview, however, is not provided in the source, so exactly what he said beyond his initial social media blast remains unconfirmed.
His grievances against Ohio State were not new. Portnoy had previously been banned from doing the final hour of the show in Big Ten stadiums, something he has blamed squarely on the Buckeyes, per awfulannouncing.com. The restriction was just another layer of the friction that defined his short-lived run on the Fox set.
The split was visible before it was official. While Portnoy traveled to Columbus, Ohio, ahead of No. 5 Ohio State’s win over Illinois, the Barstool College Football Show crew did not accompany him, according to awfulannouncing.com. That separation hinted at the distance already forming between Portnoy and the traditional broadcast operation.

The pattern was consistent: Portnoy pushed, Ohio State pushed back, and Fox Sports eventually decided the headache was not worth the partnership. His Monday conversation with Glasspiegel was the latest chapter in that saga.
WHAT TO WATCH NEXT
The split is now official. Portnoy’s exit from *Big Noon Kickoff* is effective immediately, following Fox Sports’ decision last week, according to awfulannouncing.com.
The Athletic’s Andrew Marchand reported the news, and Portnoy pre-empted it with his own social media statement on Friday. That timing was deliberate: he wanted to tell his version before the report landed.
What comes next remains unclear. No future appearances or replacements have been announced in the source, and any potential role for Portnoy with Fox or *Big Noon Kickoff* is not confirmed.
The question hanging over the situation is whether Portnoy’s Barstool partnership with Fox Sports survives at all. His role on the pregame show was the flagship piece of that deal, and with it gone, the broader relationship is uncertain.
For Ohio State and Ryan Day, the immediate headache is gone. For Portnoy, the fight moves back to his own platforms, where he has spent years airing grievances against the Buckeyes without consequence.
Neither Fox Sports nor Portnoy has publicly outlined a next step. The only concrete fact is that the split happened last week, and the show will move forward without him.
Advertisement





