Sirianni's 4th-Down Calls Cost Eagles Again
Nick Sirianni made two inexplicably horrific calls to go for it on 4th down in the Eagles' loss, according to www.barstoolsports.com.
The first came at the end of the 3rd quarter on 4th and 1 — a tush push that the source describes as a 'looooooong 1.' The second was going for it on 4th and 2 from the 2-yard line while up 20-10, which resulted in an incompletion.
The Rams then went 98 yards down the field to score a touchdown on the next drive, per the source.
The source says this was 'absolutely the worst' of Sirianni's losses during his tenure. The final score of the game is not confirmed in the source.
THE TUSH PUSH THAT FAILED
The Eagles attempted the tush push on 4th and 1 at the end of the 3rd quarter, according to www.barstoolsports.com. The exact outcome of the play — whether it was stopped or converted — is not explicitly stated in the source.
What is clear is the context. The source notes the Eagles' offense had gone 3-and-out in the 3rd quarter for four straight weeks this year. That frustration may explain the gamble, but the personnel situation made it a disaster waiting to happen.
Dallas Goedert was not in the lineup. Saquon Barkley was not out there for the push. Lane Johnson was also missing, per the source. And the offensive line had been "terrible all game" according to the source.
It was 4th and 1, but the source describes it as a "looooooong 1." With the missing pieces up front and the push's primary weapon absent, the call made little sense.
"Literally anything but the tush push could have worked here," the source says.
The play did not work. The Rams took over and the momentum shifted entirely.
THE 4TH-AND-2 FROM THE 2
The Eagles’ drive that set up the disaster was actually working. Per www.barstoolsports.com, they moved 62 yards down the field on 9 straight runs, the run game finally humming after a quiet night.
Then, right before 3rd and goal, Sirianni called a timeout. The source labels it a "DUMB SACK OF SHIT ALERT," noting the offense had all the momentum and the timeout ripped it away.
The play call out of the timeout was fine, according to the source, but the snap was troubled and they gained 0 yards. That left 4th and 2 from the 2-yard line, still up 20-10.
The obvious move was a field goal, pushing the lead to 13 and forcing the Rams to need two touchdowns just to tie. Instead, per the source, Sirianni chose to go for it.
The pass fell incomplete. The exact play call and who was targeted are not in the source.
The Rams answered with a 98-yard touchdown drive, cutting the lead to three and flipping the entire game. The momentum shift was immediate, and the Eagles never recovered.
THE REACTION AND THE STAKES
The reaction from www.barstoolsports.com is blunt: Sirianni "single-handedly is the reason this team loses." The source goes further, claiming that "almost all of the losses can be pegged on him" during his tenure in Philadelphia.
The source challenges anyone to find one game where Sirianni actually helped the Eagles win. "I implore anybody to go back throughout Nick Sirianni's tenure... and find me 1 game where Nick Sirianni actually helped them win the football game," the piece reads, asking for a single instance where he "played a critical role in an Eagles win."
The source acknowledges the Eagles haven't lost a ton of games under Sirianni. But it insists this loss was "absolutely the worst."
Analytics might defend the fourth-down decision, the source concedes, anticipating "analytics dorks" who will argue the numbers supported going for it. But the momentum shift was real and immediate — the Rams answered with a 98-yard touchdown drive after the failed attempt, flipping the game's entire trajectory.
No official player or coach quotes appear in the source material. The criticism is entirely the source's opinion, unconfirmed by anyone inside the organization.
For a team that hasn't lost much under Sirianni, the stakes are now about pattern recognition. The source frames each defeat as a coaching failure rather than bad luck, and this one as the clearest example yet.
WHAT TO WATCH NEXT
For what comes next, the source offers no specifics. It does not mention the Eagles' next game, any upcoming schedule, or any injury updates for Dallas Goedert, Saquon Barkley, or Lane Johnson.
Nothing is confirmed about potential coaching changes or decisions. The source does not indicate any front-office moves or adjustments to Sirianni's staff.
What the source does do is keep the focus squarely on Sirianni's pattern of fourth-down decisions. Each loss, per www.barstoolsports.com, gets pegged on him, and this one is framed as the clearest example yet.
Fans will likely watch for Sirianni's approach in future close games, but no specifics are in the source. There is no word on whether he changes his calculus, no hint of internal pressure, and no timeline for any response.
All of that remains unconfirmed. The only certainty is the criticism itself — the source's opinion, not the team's — and the question it leaves hanging over the next fourth-down situation.
Until the Eagles play again, the watch is on Sirianni's decision-making. The source gives no reason to expect a different answer.
Advertisement
You may also like
AJ Styles on Son Avery Wrestling Too Much Like Him: 'He Will Realize He Can Be His Own Person'
AJ Styles has heard the criticism that his 19-year-old son Avery wrestles too much like him, and he addressed it directly in an interview…
Why Solo Sikoa really reunited with The Bloodline on WWE RAW
Solo Sikoa reunited with The Bloodline on WWE RAW before Money in the Bank 2026, according to www.sportskeeda.com. The return came in a backstage…
Why Stephanie Vaquer is defending her WWE Women’s World Title in a Triple Threat at MITB
On the go-home RAW before Money in the Bank 2026, Becky Lynch and Liv Morgan squared off in a No. 1 Contender's match for…
Jim Ross Set for Second Brain Procedure to Address Shunt Issue
Jim Ross took to social media on Monday evening to reveal he is set for a second brain procedure, scheduled for Wednesday, October 7,…
4 Possible Finishes for Oba Femi vs. Bronson Reed at WWE Money in the Bank 2026
The rivalry between Oba Femi and Bronson Reed has reached a fever pitch on Monday Night RAW, according to www.sportskeeda.com. The two behemoths have…
Mahomes tells Raiders rookie Mendoza to learn from Kirk Cousins, like he did from Alex Smith
Patrick Mahomes believes Raiders rookie Fernando Mendoza is in the right place, learning behind veteran quarterback Kirk Cousins. The Kansas City Chiefs quarterback compared…