The Athletics' $98M gamble backfired in brutal 64-win collapse
The Athletics finished 2026 with a 64-98 record, per www.justbaseball.com. It was a brutal collapse for a franchise that entered the year with legitimate reasons to believe the worst was behind them.
Coming off a 76-win 2025 season, the A's had improved by seven wins from 2024 and a remarkable 26 wins from 2023. The franchise's first season in Sacramento had provided enough promise to give fans hope that brighter days were ahead. The organization had finally begun to invest more heavily in its on-field product, with the 2026 payroll approaching $98 million—a franchise high for the decade and nearly a $40 million increase from their 2025 total, according to Spotrac via www.justbaseball.com.
Fans and even some pundits entered the season believing the A's could make a push for the playoffs and return to October baseball for the first time since the COVID-shortened 2020 season, according to www.justbaseball.com. No specific playoff odds or predictions have been confirmed, but the expectation was clear: this young core was ready to contend.
Instead, injuries and regression ravaged the roster, per www.justbaseball.com. The optimism never translated to the field, and what began as a season filled with promise quickly became one of the most disappointing campaigns in a decade consisting of seemingly only disappointing campaigns.
THE $98 MILLION INVESTMENT
The Athletics’ 2026 payroll approached $98 million, a franchise high for the decade, per Spotrac via www.justbaseball.com. That represented nearly a $40 million increase from their 2025 total, according to www.justbaseball.com. Exact payroll figures beyond "approached $98 million" are not confirmed.
The spending spree came after two straight years of tangible progress. The team had improved by seven wins from 2024 and 26 wins from 2023, per www.justbaseball.com, giving front-office executives reason to believe the investment was justified.
What did that $98 million buy? A 64-win season. The Athletics finished with a 64-98 record, per www.justbaseball.com, and the collapse was swift enough to make the franchise's decade of struggles feel almost routine.
According to www.justbaseball.com, 2026 was one of the most disappointing campaigns in a decade of disappointing campaigns. The payroll was a statement of intent. The results were a statement of reality.
INJURIES AND REGRESSION STRIKE
The injury bug and regression made their way through the A's clubhouse, according to www.justbaseball.com, and the results were devastating.
Nick Kurtz, the 2025 AL Rookie of the Year, failed to reach 100 games in 2026, per www.justbaseball.com. Jacob Wilson, the 2025 AL Rookie of the Year runner-up, also failed to reach 100 games, according to www.justbaseball.com. Two of the brightest young talents in the sport spent significant chunks of the season unavailable.
Brent Rooker, the team's All-Star slugger from the previous season, appeared in fewer than 50 games, per www.justbaseball.com. A lineup that was supposed to be the foundation of a playoff push instead watched its most dangerous bat sit in the dugout.
Specific injury details or timelines for any of these players are not in the source. What is clear is that the combination of absences and declining performance left the Athletics without the core that had fueled their optimism.
The young core that had won 26 more games in 2024 to 2025 than in 2023 simply could not stay on the field together.
THE WEIGHT OF EXPECTATIONS
The 2026 season was the franchise's first in Sacramento, a move that had provided promise for brighter days, per www.justbaseball.com. The days of relocation turmoil and widespread fan angst appeared to be fading into the rearview mirror, according to the same site. For the first time in years, the conversation around the franchise was about baseball, not ballparks.
That optimism was built on something real. Entering the season, the Athletics boasted one of the brightest young cores in the sport, per www.justbaseball.com, with even more dynamic talent developing in the upper levels of the minors and seemingly close to debuts. The organization had also finally shown an improved willingness to spend, according to www.justbaseball.com, backing the young roster with a payroll approaching $98 million.
No specific fan sentiment or attendance figures have been confirmed, so the emotional toll cannot be quantified. But the ingredients for hope were all there: a rising core, a new home, and an owner finally opening the checkbook.
That is what made the collapse so brutal. The promise was not a mirage—it was a foundation that never got the chance to stand. The payroll was real. The talent was real. The regression and injuries were just as real, and they hit all at once.
For fans, the 2026 season was not another year of losing. It was the year the plan was supposed to pay off. Instead, it became the kind of campaign that makes a fanbase wish it had all been a bad dream.
WHAT TO WATCH NEXT
Despite the doom and gloom, the 2026 season was not without its silver linings, according to www.justbaseball.com. The same young core that was expected to carry the team into contention remains intact and is still viewed as a foundation for the future.
Nick Kurtz, the 2025 AL Rookie of the Year, and Jacob Wilson, that award’s runner-up, are both still central to that vision. Their injury-shortened campaigns were the biggest blows of the collapse, but the talent that made them franchise cornerstones has not disappeared.
Beyond that duo, www.justbaseball.com reports that dynamic talent in the upper levels of the minors is seemingly not far from making major league debuts. The pipeline that fueled the optimism entering 2026 has not dried up—it may simply need another season to arrive.
No specific next game, return date, or front-office plans are confirmed in the source. Whether the organization adds to its payroll again or leans on its internal options remains an open question that has not been answered.
What is clear is that the pieces are still in place. The hope that was crushed by a 64-win season was built on real players, and those players are still on the roster or close to it. The plan may have backfired this year, but the foundation was never the problem.
Advertisement
You may also like
Gabby Williams' 25 points lead Valkyries to Game 1 win over Aces
No. 2 Golden State defeated No. 3 Las Vegas 71-60 in Game 1 of the WNBA semifinals, grabbing a one-game lead in the best-of-five…
Angel Reese first of WNBA's new stars with real shot at title
Angel Reese is the first of the WNBA's new stars with a real shot at a title, according to www.highposthoops.com. The Atlanta Dream are…
Angel Reese leads Dream to 92-82 upset over Liberty in semifinal opener
The Atlanta Dream opened the WNBA semifinals with a 92-82 upset of the New York Liberty at State Farm Arena on Oct. 4, 2026.…
No. 1 combo guard King Gibson commits to LSU over Arkansas, Louisville, Providence
King Gibson, the No. 1 ranked combo guard in the 2027 class, has committed to LSU, he told Rivals. The 6-foot-4 senior out of…
Dan Hurley compares NIL roster costs to a poker game: 'Hard to know what's real'
Speaking at Big East Media Day, UConn coach Dan Hurley compared NIL roster cost conversations to a poker game, per sports.yahoo.com. "I look at…
Five-star SG Jordan Page picks UConn over UNC, boosts Huskies' 2027 class
Five-star shooting guard Jordan Page has committed to UConn, he announced, giving the Huskies a major piece of their 2027 recruiting class. Page, a…