Ben Johnson's ego costs him a shot at NFL history with Bears

Ben Johnson has avoided joining an elite list of NFL coaches, per Ben Solak of ESPN. The Chicago Bears head coach could have become just the fourth coach in league history to win three of his first four games with three different quarterbacks, joining Tom Coughlin, Al Saunders, and Don Shula.
He didn't make that list, Solak wrote, "if not for the fact that he got smarmy and made Case Keenum, not Tyson Bagent, the starting quarterback in Week 4 by giving Keenum the first snap from under center … and then played Bagent the rest of the game." Keenum took that first snap against the New York Jets last Sunday before Bagent came in for the rest of the game.
Solak added that Johnson "wanted to make a point after it was reported this week that Bagent was the Week 4 starter before Johnson had announced his selection." That report that Bagent was the starter before Johnson's announcement has not been confirmed by the team.
With Caleb Williams still battling a hamstring injury, Johnson has relied on his backups. Keenum started in Week 3 and Bagent in Week 4, and both delivered wins.
THE WEEK 4 QUARTERBACK DECISION
Keenum took the snap, and then Bagent took over for the rest of the game. Bagent completed 25 of 34 pass attempts for 268 yards in the 23-12 win over the Jets.

The decision to give Keenum that first snap is what kept Johnson off the exclusive list, per Solak. But the reason behind it is not confirmed; Solak's interpretation that Johnson "got smarmy" is his opinion, not a team statement.
The Bears' quarterback situation remains fluid. Williams is still battling a hamstring injury, and Johnson confirmed that Bagent will start at quarterback against the Green Bay Packers this Sunday.
BACKUP QUARTERBACK SUCCESS
Backup quarterbacks have carried Johnson through the first month. With Caleb Williams still battling a hamstring injury, Keenum and Bagent have delivered consecutive wins in Weeks 3 and 4, respectively.
Keenum started in Week 3 and led a 27-7 win over the Eagles, completing 24 of 34 pass attempts for 247 yards and 2 touchdowns. Bagent followed in Week 4 with a 23-12 win over the Jets, completing 25 of 34 passes for 268 yards.
The efficiency is striking: both backups completed over 70 percent of their throws, and both wins came against playoff-caliber opponents. Johnson has not had to sacrifice production while Williams recovers.

Williams' return date has not been mentioned in the source, so it remains unclear when the starter will be back under center. What is clear is that Johnson has found a working formula with his depth chart.
Bagent's numbers in Week 4 — 268 yards on 25 completions — nearly matched Keenum's Week 3 output of 247 yards. The consistency suggests Johnson's system is elevating whoever takes the snap, not just the starter.
SOLAK'S CRITIQUE
Ben Solak of ESPN did not hold back in his critique of Johnson's Week 4 decision. Solak wrote that Johnson "got smarmy" by giving Keenum the first snap from under center before turning the game over to Bagent.
"Johnson wanted to make a point after it was reported this week that Bagent was the Week 4 starter before Johnson had announced his selection," Solak wrote.
The ESPN analyst framed the move as a direct response to reports that Bagent had been pegged as the starter before Johnson made his own announcement. Whether Johnson actually intended to make a point is not confirmed — it remains Solak's assertion.

Solak's comments stand as the only direct reaction in the source material, making his words the sharpest public assessment of Johnson's quarterback handling. The criticism carries extra weight because it came after a win, not a loss.
Johnson's choice to start Keenum for one snap denied him a place alongside Tom Coughlin, Al Saunders, and Don Shula as the only coaches to win three of their first four games with three different quarterbacks. Instead of chasing that history, Johnson stuck to his own process — and the Bears walked away with a 23-12 victory.
WHAT TO WATCH NEXT
Johnson confirmed that Tyson Bagent will start at quarterback against the Green Bay Packers this Sunday. Caleb Williams is still battling a hamstring injury, per the source, and his status for the Packers game is not specified beyond that ongoing issue.
The Bears have won in Weeks 3 and 4 with backup quarterbacks, so Sunday's matchup will be another test of the depth that has carried Chicago so far. Bagent gets the nod after completing 25 of 34 pass attempts for 268 yards in the 23-12 win over the Jets.
Keenum delivered his own clinic in Week 3, completing 24 of 34 passes for 247 yards and two touchdowns in a 27-7 rout of the Eagles. Now the rotation lands on Bagent again, this time against a Packers defense that will have had a full week to prepare for him.
Johnson's quarterback handling has already drawn scrutiny from ESPN's Ben Solak, who argued the coach's Week 4 decision cost him a shot at NFL history. Whether that criticism lingers into Sunday depends on how Bagent performs in a divisional game with playoff implications.
The Packers game will reveal whether Johnson's backup strategy is sustainable or a short-term fix. Bagent's start is confirmed; anything beyond that remains unanswered until kickoff.
Advertisement




