PFF's top 2027 QB prospects: Mensah dominates, Sayin flawless from clean pocket

Darian Mensah of Miami leads all qualifying Power Four quarterbacks with a 92.6 PFF passing grade through five weeks, according to www.pff.com.
The Miami quarterback also paces the group in adjusted completion percentage, passer rating, and EPA per play, per PFF. Specific numbers for those categories are not provided in the source.
Five weeks of college football have given NFL evaluators their first extended look at the quarterbacks who could define the 2027 draft class, per PFF. Some of the position's most notable names have performed as expected, while others have either elevated or hurt their standing through the opening stretch of the season.
PFF has also started turning its attention toward the draft, expanding its Big Board to 150 players as the evaluation and scouting process ramps up. Mensah's early command of the passing metrics puts him at the center of that scrutiny as the top quarterback prospect on the board.
SAYIN'S CLEAN-POCKET PERFECTION

Julian Sayin of Ohio State ranks second among the qualifying Power Four quarterback group with a 92.5 PFF passing grade, according to www.pff.com.
The headline number, though, is his work from a clean pocket. Sayin leads the nation with a 94.0 PFF grade in that situation, per PFF, showcasing elite efficiency when he is not under pressure.
That clean-pocket dominance has carried him through the first five weeks of the season, as noted by PFF, and places him directly behind Darian Mensah in the early quarterback pecking order.
No details on Sayin's performance under pressure or other situational splits are in the source. Those numbers have not been confirmed.
CARR'S NEGATIVE-PLAY AVOIDANCE

Few quarterbacks have avoided negative plays as well as CJ Carr. The Notre Dame signal-caller owns a 3.1% negatively graded play rate, the second-lowest among qualifying Power Four quarterbacks, per www.pff.com.
That rate helps Carr earn a 92.0 PFF passing grade, according to PFF, placing him just behind both Mensah and Sayin in the early top-10 quarterback prospect list on PFF's Big Board after Week 5.
Carr's ability to minimize negative plays stands out in the early-season evaluation, per PFF. While he does not lead the group in raw passing numbers, his consistency on a down-to-down basis is what separates him from the pack.
No specific game-by-game breakdown or comparison to the lowest negatively graded play rate is in the source. Those details have not been confirmed.
MANNING AND MOORE SPLIT

Arch Manning hasn't matched the box-score production of some other top quarterback prospects, but his 80.4 PFF passing grade ranks 21st among qualifying Power Four quarterbacks, per www.pff.com. His 5.9% big-time throw rate is tied for 13th.
The split comes when defenses change their approach. Manning grades 89.1 when not blitzed versus 63.8 when blitzed, according to PFF — a dramatic drop that shows how much he thrives with a clean look.
Dante Moore of Oregon presents the opposite profile. Moore owns a 130.0 passer rating (sixth), a 79.8% adjusted completion percentage (ninth) and 9.5 yards per attempt (12th), per PFF.
Against pressure, Moore grades 87.6 when blitzed but only 74.6 when not blitzed, the exact inverse of Manning's split, according to PFF. Where Manning excels with time, Moore produces under duress.
These contrasting blitz responses could shape NFL evaluations as the season progresses, per PFF. Teams weighing the two quarterbacks will have to decide which skill set translates more reliably to the pro game.

No direct comparison or draft projection beyond the grades and ranks has been made in the source. Those conclusions have not been confirmed.
WHAT TO WATCH NEXT
PFF has expanded its Big Board to 150 players as the evaluation and scouting process ramps up, according to www.pff.com. That expansion comes after five weeks of data, with the top-10 quarterback list based on Week 5 grades and more weeks of tape still to come.
These early performances will provide the foundation for a much longer evaluation process for quarterback-needy NFL teams, per PFF. The grades from the opening stretch are a starting point, not a verdict, as the scouting cycle extends deep into the winter.
No specific upcoming games, dates, or changes to the Big Board are mentioned in the source. Those details have not been confirmed.
For those tracking the full picture, PFF+ subscription is available at $99.99 a year — $8.33 a month billed annually — for full access, as noted in the source. The next set of grades will arrive with Week 6, adding another layer to the evaluations of Mensah, Sayin, Carr, Manning and Moore as the 2027 picture sharpens.
Advertisement





