The .40-caliber pistol that ended Versace's life — and the man who never faced a trial
The morning of July 15, 1997, was already hot on Ocean Drive.
Gianni Versace had walked to a café and was coming back to Casa Casuarina, the mansion at 1116 Ocean Drive.
He reached the steps.
A shooter approached and fired two shots at close range with a pistol.
Two shots, close range, and then the shooter was gone.
He fled on a bicycle.
The bicycle was abandoned later.
A jacket was left behind.
The pistol was not found at the scene.
The shooter's identity was not yet established at that moment.
No witness is named in the record as having seen the shooter's face on those steps.
The man on the bicycle was a figure in motion, and the gun went with him.
Versace was pronounced dead at Jackson Memorial Hospital.
The abruptness is the fact.
A morning walk, a café, a return home.
Then the steps, the shots, the bicycle.
The gun was a .40-caliber pistol.
It was not at the scene.
It would not be found for eight days.
Where it went, and who carried it, were questions the scene did not answer.
The record leaves that moment open.
The shooter was a man on a bicycle.
That is what the record shows.
That is all the record shows.
THE MANHUNT
The FBI had been searching for Andrew Cunanan since April 1997.
He was a 27-year-old drifter, and he was wanted for the murders of three other men: David Madson, Jeffrey Trail, and Lee Miglin.
By the time Gianni Versace was shot, Cunanan was already the subject of a multi-state manhunt.
He had been placed on the FBI's Ten Most Wanted list.
The source does not specify the exact date he was placed on that list.
It does not specify the precise sequence of how eyewitness accounts led to his identification.
Police identified Cunanan as the shooter from eyewitness accounts and physical evidence.
He abandoned a bicycle at the scene.
He left a jacket behind.
The investigation was led by the Miami Beach Police Department, with a lead detective.
The manhunt was closing in.
Cunanan was mobile.
He evaded capture across state lines.
That is what the record shows about the hunt.
It was a nationwide search for one man.
It was a search that would end eight days later, on a houseboat in Miami Beach.
EIGHT DAYS
The houseboat was a floating room in a marina off Miami Beach.
It was found eight days after the shots on Ocean Drive.
Inside was the body of Andrew Cunanan.
He was dead from a self-inflicted gunshot wound.
The .40-caliber pistol was there too.
Ballistics matched that weapon to the Versace shooting.
That is the short arc of the record.
The longer arc is what the record does not contain.
The source does not state who found the body.
The source does not state the exact time of death.
The medical examiner's name is not in the record.
His autopsy findings were reported in coverage, confirming two gunshot wounds to the head and neck.
Those findings were reported.
They were never tested in a courtroom.
No prosecutor was assigned.
No defense attorney was assigned.
No judge was assigned.
There was no trial.
There was no cross-examination of the ballistics match.
There was no challenge to the eyewitness accounts.
There was no argument about the bicycle or the jacket.
The identification of Cunanan as the shooter rests on the documented record.
It rests on abandoned evidence.
It rests on a matched weapon.
It rests on a dead man.
None of it was ever tested.
The houseboat where Cunanan died was later removed.
The case remains closed.
The record identifies a shooter.
The record never produced a verdict.
THE CASE THAT NEVER WAS
There was no trial.
Andrew Cunanan died by suicide on July 23, 1997, eight days after the murder.
He was never charged.
He was never arrested.
He was never tried — not for the murder of Gianni Versace, and not for the three murders that preceded it.
No prosecutor was assigned.
No defense attorney was assigned.
No judge was assigned.
The Miami Beach Police Department closed its investigation after Cunanan's death was confirmed.
The case was closed without a conviction.
No one else was ever charged in connection with the murder.
The evidence existed.
Eyewitness accounts placed him on the steps of Casa Casuarina.
A jacket and a bicycle were abandoned nearby.
The .40-caliber pistol was found on the houseboat where he died.
Ballistics matched the weapon to the shooting.
That is what the record holds.
That is also where the record stops.
There is no prosecution theory of the case, because no prosecution ever began.
There is no defense theory of the case, because no defense was ever mounted.
Any interpretation of what either side might have argued is not in the record.
That would require a trial.
The case remains closed.
The record identifies a shooter.
The record never produced a verdict.
She was not the only one left without an answer.
AND THE STORY STILL ISN'T OVER
The record identifies a shooter.
The record never produced a verdict.
Andrew Cunanan is dead.
The houseboat where he died was later removed.
The .40-caliber pistol was found there.
No one else was ever charged.
The Versace family continues to operate the fashion house.
Donatella Versace has served as artistic director.
Santo Versace has been involved in the company's business operations.
The victim's partner was present at the scene that morning.
He was named in coverage as a witness.
Cunanan's mother, Mary Ann Cunanan, was named in coverage after his death.
The case remains closed.
No prosecutor was assigned.
No defense attorney was assigned.
No judge was assigned.
There was no trial, no conviction, no appeal.
The legal record is permanently silent.
Not because the evidence was weak.
Not because the accused was acquitted.
Not because the charges were dropped.
Because the accused died before an arrest could be made.
It is a closed file.
It is also an open wound.
No hearing is pending.
No motion is scheduled.
No decision is expected.
That would require a case.
The source does not state any pending hearing, motion, or decision.
The case is closed with no next concrete step in the record.
She was on the ground below.
The fashion house keeps its name.
The investigation keeps its conclusion.
The record keeps its silence.
Advertisement
You may also like
The clip-on tie left behind that made FBI agents look twice
The clip-on tie sat on the seat, a plain thing, dark and cheap. It was found after the plane landed, after the man was…
The pharmacy clerk's last stop before vanishing — what police found next
She was at the counter at the pharmacy, and he was going to meet a contractor about a job. Robert Piest was 15 years…
The courtroom theatrics that turned a murder trial into a national spectacle
In June 1970, as the trial opened, the three female defendants walked into the courtroom with shaved heads. Swastikas were carved on their foreheads.…
The cellphone video that placed Alex Murdaugh at the kennels — and the timeline he swore was wrong
Paul Murdaugh’s phone was recording on June 7, 2021, at the dog kennels on the family estate, Moselle. The video was casual, unplanned, the…
The surgical glove blood evidence that reopened the MacDonald case
The surgical glove turned up late. It was not in the initial police report, that first chaotic inventory of the house on Fort Bragg.…
The church floppy disk that finally unmasked the BTK killer
The package arrived at the Wichita TV station in 2004, and the station staff knew the name on it before they opened it. BTK…