The QuickBooks edits a business partner made after the McStay family vanished
The dogs were in the backyard.
The vehicles were still in the driveway at the Fallbrook home, and the front door was unlocked, but the McStay family was gone.
Joseph McStay, his wife, and their two young sons vanished on February 4, 2010.
No signs of a struggle. No obvious foul play. The initial investigation found nothing to explain it.
Months passed. The case went cold.
Then, in November 2013, two dirt bikers found human remains in shallow graves near Victorville.
The remains were identified as the McStay family.
Joseph and Summer had been beaten to death. The children had also been killed.
The accused, Charles "Chase" Merritt, was a business associate of Joseph.
He had worked with Joseph on water-feature installation projects.
He was arrested in November 2014 and charged with four counts of first-degree murder.
Prosecutors later presented a detail that raised a question: Merritt had used Joseph's QuickBooks accounting software after the family vanished.
He was attempting to alter records, they said.
The exact nature of those edits and their timing are not specified in the record.
What did a business partner do with the books after a family disappeared?
That would require evidence. The record does not establish the full picture.
THE BUSINESS PARTNER
He was the last person known to have spoken with Joseph McStay.
Phone records said so, and the record keeps that detail intact.
Charles "Chase" Merritt had worked with Joseph on various projects.
One of those projects was a water-feature installation business.
How close were they, exactly?
The specific nature of the business relationship is not detailed in the record.
No prior conflicts are in the record either.
After the family vanished, Merritt logged into Joseph’s QuickBooks accounting software.
Prosecutors said he attempted to alter records.
What he changed, and when, is not specified in the source material.
Cell phone records and GPS data placed Merritt in the area of the graves.
That placement was around the time of the disappearances.
It is a location. It is also a question.
The defense argued the evidence was circumstantial.
Merritt had no motive, the defense said.
Not because the record proves a motive exists.
But because the record does not establish one.
The partnership was real. The edits were real. The phone records were real.
What went wrong between them?
That would require evidence.
THE DESERT GRAVES
They vanished on February 4, 2010.
The San Bernardino County Sheriff’s Department found no obvious signs of foul play at the McStay home.
The dogs were in the backyard. The vehicles were still there.
For months, the record shows, the case went cold.
Then, in November 2013, two men riding dirt bikes in the Mojave Desert near Victorville found human remains in two shallow graves.
The remains were identified as the McStay family.
Joseph and Summer had been beaten to death.
The children had also been killed.
The murder weapon was never identified.
That detail is not established in the record.
It is a fact the investigation could not fix.
The graves were shallow. The desert was wide.
What was found was enough to end the search but not enough to explain the end.
The initial investigation had moved slowly.
The home was not thoroughly searched at first. The disappearance was not immediately treated as a potential crime.
Those missteps would be criticized later.
For now, the bones in the desert were the only answer to three years of questions.
Joseph was gone. Summer was gone.
The two boys were gone.
The weapon that did it — the record does not say.
No hammer was matched. No bat was tied to the scene.
The prosecution would point to phone records and QuickBooks edits.
The defense would call it circumstantial.
But the graves themselves were not a theory.
They were found.
And what happened in them left four bodies and one open question: with what?
THE QUICKBOOKS EDITS
The record shows the QuickBooks edits, but it does not show their exact content.
Prosecutors said Merritt opened Joseph’s accounting software after the family vanished.
The edits, they argued, were an attempt to alter records tied to financial fraud.
The alleged fraud involved Joseph’s business, the water-feature installation work the two men shared.
To the prosecution, the edits were the hinge: kill the family, then clean the books.
That was the motive offered to the jury.
The defense answered with a different word: speculation.
Merritt had no motive, his attorney argued; the phone records placed him near the graves, but proximity is not proof.
The QuickBooks edits, the defense said, proved nothing about murder.
They proved a man touched a computer.
The trial opened in January 2019.
Merritt faced four counts of first-degree murder, one for each member of the family.
The prosecution built its case on records: cell data, GPS coordinates, the accounting log.
The defense built its case on the gaps between those records.
What the edits said, exactly, was never specified in the record.
How they tied to the alleged fraud was never specified either.
That remains unestablished.
A jury heard both narratives.
In June 2019, they found Merritt guilty on all four counts.
He was sentenced to life without parole.
The conviction rests on a story of fraud covered by violence.
The alternative story—that the evidence was circumstantial and the motive invented—lost in that courtroom.
Which narrative does the record support?
The record supports the edits existing.
It does not support what they contained.
AND THE STORY STILL ISN'T OVER
Merritt is incarcerated at a California state prison, serving life without parole.
He has maintained his innocence and has filed appeals.
His appeals have been unsuccessful as of the latest reports.
That is all the record specifies about them.
It does not establish whether any petition is currently pending.
The investigation was criticized for early missteps.
A delay in thoroughly searching the McStay home.
A failure to immediately treat the disappearance as a potential crime.
Those choices shaped what followed.
They shaped what could never be recovered.
The family’s deaths remain a subject of public interest.
Documentaries examine the case.
News coverage continues to return to it.
Joseph’s father has spoken publicly about the loss.
Summer’s mother has spoken publicly about the loss.
They have described their children and grandchildren in interviews.
The record preserves their words.
It does not preserve an ending that satisfies them.
The conviction stands.
The sentence stands.
The questions do not.
Was the home searched soon enough?
Was the case treated as a crime soon enough?
Was the QuickBooks edit the whole story?
That would require evidence.
The record does not establish it.
Merritt remains where the jury placed him.
The family remains where the desert placed them.
The story is closed in one sense.
It is not closed in another.
Advertisement
You may also like
The cell tower data that put Adnan Syed near Leakin Park — and the questions it left behind
On January 13, 1999, Hae Min Lee, an 18-year-old senior at Woodlawn High School, disappeared after leaving school. Her car was found on February…
One anonymous note sent police to a witness — is that note the key to Hae Min Lee's 1999 murder case?
The note was anonymous. It arrived after Hae Min Lee's body was found on February 9, 1999, in Leakin Park, partially buried. She had…
The last video Paul Murdaugh filmed minutes before the shots that killed him and his mother
He was 22, and he was filming his dogs. Paul Murdaugh held up his cell phone at the family's hunting estate in Colleton County,…
The pillowcase that tied a kidnapper to Polly Klaas — and the parole officer who spotted him
Two girls lay on the floor of the bedroom, their hands and feet bound. They had been tied up, but they had not been…
The pajama top that told the FBI a different story than Jeffrey MacDonald's
The pajama top was folded on an evidence table, and it told two stories at once. On the night of February 17, 1970, at…
The 10 p.m. check that found an open door and an empty bed
The key turned in the lock at approximately 10:00 p.m. on May 3, 2007. Kate McCann stepped into the holiday apartment in Praia da…