Why a handleless hatchet in the cellar never settled the Lizzie Borden case
The handleless hatchet sits in the cellar of 92 Second Street, Fall River, in every retelling of the case.
It was found there after the murders on August 4, 1892.
It was examined, and it showed no clear blood evidence.
The source does not state who found it, or when.
It is not mentioned in any trial testimony in the source.
Its role is only in the investigation summary.
So why does a weapon with no blood on it stay so central to the story?
Why does a tool with no handle, no stain, no witness, no chain of custody, keep appearing in the narrative?
Why does the record keep it close, even as it refuses to connect it to anything?
The answer is not in the hatchet itself.
The source lists the murder weapon as "a hatchet or axe, never conclusively identified."
That is the whole record: a weapon type, a handleless example, and nothing linking the two.
Whether the hatchet was ever linked to the murders by any evidence is not established.
It is a real exhibit. It is also a dead end.
The cellar holds it. The case holds it. The evidence does not.
AUGUST 4, 1892
The morning of August 4, 1892, was hot.
Inside 92 Second Street, Fall River, the heat pressed against the walls of a small, crowded house.
Between approximately 9:00 and 11:00 a.m., two people were killed there.
Andrew Jackson Borden was found on a couch in the first-floor sitting room.
His face was nearly split by an axe-like weapon.
His second wife, Abby Durfee Borden, was found in an upstairs guest bedroom.
She had been killed by repeated blows from a hatchet or axe.
The maid, Bridget Sullivan, discovered the bodies.
Family members followed her into the rooms.
The exact time of death is not specified; only that window of 9 to 11 a.m. is given.
Lizzie Andrew Borden, Andrew's younger daughter, was at the house during those hours.
She was there when her father was killed.
She was there when her stepmother was killed.
The house was not large.
The sitting room was downstairs.
The guest bedroom was upstairs.
The murders happened in a space where movement could be heard, doors could be opened, footsteps could carry.
No record states what Lizzie heard that morning.
No record states what she saw.
The maid was the last person known to have seen both victims alive.
The family physician was called to the scene.
The medical examiner performed the autopsies.
The bodies were there, in the heat, in the small house.
The weapon was a hatchet or axe.
It was never conclusively identified.
THE INVESTIGATION AND THE TRIAL
She was arrested on August 11, 1892, and charged with two counts of first-degree murder.
The investigation was conducted by the Fall River police under Marshal John Fleet.
It was not a careful investigation.
Neighbors and family members moved through the house before police secured it.
The crime scene was poorly preserved.
Lizzie gave conflicting statements about her whereabouts.
She claimed she had been in the barn.
No evidence supported this.
A key piece of evidence was her inquest testimony.
It was later ruled inadmissible at trial.
The reason: she had not been warned she was a suspect.
The family physician testified at the inquest that he saw Lizzie burning a dress in the kitchen stove days after the murders.
She said it was an old paint-stained garment.
The trial began on June 5, 1893, in New Bedford.
The prosecution presented circumstantial evidence.
The defense attacked the quality of the investigation.
The jury deliberated about 90 minutes.
On June 20, 1893, they returned a verdict of not guilty.
She was acquitted of both murders.
No direct evidence linked Lizzie to the killings.
That is what the record states explicitly.
The handleless hatchet in the cellar showed no clear blood evidence.
It could not be tied to the crime.
The murder weapon was never conclusively identified.
That would require evidence.
The case was never reopened.
No one else was ever charged.
The house at 92 Second Street still stands.
It operates as a bed-and-breakfast and museum.
The case remains officially unsolved.
TWO STORIES, ONE HATCHET
The prosecution argued that Lizzie Borden had motive — resentment of her stepmother and fear of being cut out of her father's will.
It was a motive built on family feeling, not on a fingerprint or a witness.
No direct evidence linked her to the killings.
The defense argued that no eyewitness or physical evidence connected her to the murders at all.
They attacked the quality of the investigation.
Neighbors and family members had moved through the house before police secured it.
The handleless hatchet from the cellar was examined.
It showed no clear blood evidence.
It could not be tied to the crime.
Whether the hatchet was ever considered a serious suspect weapon is not established.
The source only says it was examined.
No record shows any testimony about the hatchet at trial.
It appears only in the investigation summary.
The inquest testimony, which might have been damaging, was excluded from trial.
She had not been warned that she was a suspect.
So the jury heard a case built on circumstance.
They deliberated for approximately 90 minutes.
They returned a verdict of not guilty.
Was the hatchet the weapon? The record does not say.
Was it a red herring? The record does not say.
Was it even relevant? That would require evidence.
The jury heard the prosecution's story of motive and resentment.
They heard the defense's story of a broken investigation.
They chose the second.
The case remains officially unsolved.
AND THE STORY STILL ISN'T OVER
She left the courtroom with a name that no longer fit her.
Lizzie Borden returned to Fall River, to a new home on the hill with her sister Emma.
They called it Maplecroft.
She changed her name to Lizbeth A. Borden.
Not because the verdict had settled anything.
Because the town had made her a rhyme, and she wanted out of it.
She and Emma drifted apart in the years that followed.
Emma moved out in 1905.
Lizzie Borden died on June 1, 1927, in Fall River.
She was 66.
Emma died nine days later, on June 10, 1927.
Two sisters, nine days apart, both buried in Oak Grove Cemetery.
The case was never reopened.
No one else was ever charged.
No one has ever been convicted.
The Borden house at 92 Second Street still stands.
It is a bed-and-breakfast now, and a museum.
Guests sleep in the rooms where the bodies were found.
What the record does not establish: new evidence, a confession, a conviction.
What the record does establish: a handleless hatchet in the cellar, no blood on it, no owner claimed it.
The murder weapon was never conclusively identified.
The rhyme outlived them all.
"Lizzie Borden took an axe" — a rhyme, not a record.
The record says she was acquitted, and the case remains officially unsolved.
She was on the ground below, in a sense — beneath the weight of a story she could not shed.
Maplecroft is gone from her name, but not from the telling.
The house takes guests.
The case takes no answers.
One hundred years later, the question still hangs over the sitting-room couch.
Who swung the hatchet?
Who carried it down to the cellar?
Who left it there, handleless, for someone else to find?
That would require evidence.
The record has none.
Advertisement
You may also like
The fishing trip Scott Peterson said he took — and the boat bought weeks before
On December 24, 2002, Scott Peterson told police he had been fishing alone at the Berkeley Marina that morning. It was a small claim,…
The 7:09 PM call that placed Adnan Syed near Leakin Park — and what the defense said about it
The call came in at 7:09 PM on January 13, 1999. It was placed to Jay Wilds's home. That was the night Hae Min…
The 1995 Oklahoma bombing that left 168 dead — and one man's sentence still stands
The Ryder truck was gone. The axle was not. On April 19, 1995, a rented truck packed with ammonium nitrate and fuel oil exploded…
The severed head found by two fishermen that changed an abduction case forever
The head surfaced in a drainage canal along the Florida Turnpike near Vero Beach, about 120 miles north of Hollywood. Two fishermen found it…
The 1987 witness sighting that didn't stop the Green River Killer
A witness reported seeing Gary Ridgway with a victim. The year was 1987. The report was made to police working the Green River Killer…
The taunting smiley-face letters that led to a serial killer's downfall
The letters arrived unsigned, except for one thing. A circle. Two dots. A curved line. A smiley face, drawn in pen at the bottom…