The 10:30 p.m. intruder, a pillowcase, and the two friends who freed themselves — how Polly Klaas's case broke open
The door was unlocked.
It was October 1, 1993, around 10:30 p.m., and an intruder walked into a home in Petaluma, California, a small city north of San Francisco.
Three girls were at a slumber party.
The intruder tied them up and placed pillowcases over their heads.
He demanded money.
Then he abducted one girl, 12-year-old Polly Klaas, and left the other two bound but alive.
The two friends freed themselves.
They alerted Polly's mother, who was in another part of the house and had not heard the intrusion.
That is what the case summary records.
Who the intruder was at that moment is not established in the record.
Not by the unlocked door.
Not by the pillowcases.
Not by the demand for money.
The record shows an intrusion at 10:30 p.m., three girls tied up, one taken.
It does not show a name.
The abduction triggered one of the largest searches in California history.
Thousands of volunteers joined.
National media attention followed.
They searched fields, roads, and woods.
They searched for weeks.
The two friends who freed themselves could describe what happened inside that room.
They could describe the bindings.
They could describe the pillowcases.
They could not describe who took her.
That would require evidence.
The search went on.
THE SEARCH
The search went on.
It became one of the largest in California history, with thousands of volunteers fanning out across Petaluma and national media camped on the story.
The case summary records that scale. It does not record the exact timeline of the search efforts; that detail is not established in the record.
For nearly two months, the investigation yielded no solid leads.
The focus fell on local sex offenders and persons of interest. Names were checked. Alibis were tested. Nothing held.
Then, on November 30, 1993, the case turned.
A parolee named Richard Allen Davis was arrested. He had a long criminal record, and the tip came from a former cellmate's girlfriend.
Davis led authorities to Polly's body.
She was found in a shallow grave in a wooded area near Cloverdale, about 60 miles from Petaluma.
She had been strangled.
Not a gun. Not a knife. Strangulation.
The search that had covered so much ground ended at a grave. The volunteers went home. The media had their answer, and it was not the one anyone wanted.
Two months of frustration, then a single tip, then a body. That is how the record runs.
What happened in the interrogation room? The case summary does not say. What Davis told authorities, beyond leading them to the grave, is not established here.
It is enough to say he led them there. It is enough to say what they found.
THE PALM PRINT
The palm print was on a bedpost in Polly's bedroom.
The case summary records it as a significant piece of evidence, one that matched Davis.
Fibers from Davis's clothing were found at the crime scene.
Fibers from Davis's clothing were found on Polly's body.
The prosecution presented evidence that Davis had been in the Petaluma area on the night of the abduction.
The defense argued the palm print could have been left during an earlier visit.
The prosecution countered with timeline evidence.
The exact nature of that timeline evidence is not specified in the record.
It is a gap the record does not fill.
What the record does establish is the charge: first-degree murder with special circumstances.
Kidnapping.
Burglary.
Use of a deadly weapon.
The knife that cut the bindings on the two friends counted as the weapon.
The cause of death was strangulation, not the blade.
So the palm print sat on a bedpost, and the fibers tied a man to a room, and the charge sheet listed the ways the law said he had entered and taken and killed.
The defense said the print was old.
The prosecution said the timing did not allow it.
Which version held? The record does not say at this stage.
It says only that the print matched, that the fibers matched, that the man had been near the town that night.
That would require a jury to weigh.
That would require a trial.
THE TRIAL
The trial began in June 1996 in Sonoma County Superior Court.
The prosecution sought the death penalty.
The defense argued that Davis's troubled childhood and substance abuse mitigated his culpability.
What else the defense argued is not in the record.
The record holds the charge, the evidence, the verdict.
On August 5, 1996, the jury convicted Davis on all counts.
All counts.
The counts included first-degree murder with special circumstances: kidnapping, burglary, use of a deadly weapon.
Then came the penalty phase.
The jury recommended death.
On September 26, 1996, the judge sentenced Davis to death.
The verdict was a weighing.
The fibers, the palm print, the timeline — all of it placed before twelve people.
They weighed it.
They returned a conviction.
They returned a sentence.
The legal process closed, but the case did not.
Davis went to death row.
The appeals would last for decades.
Not because the evidence was thin.
But because the process is long.
The gravity of the verdict was a door shut.
The gravity of the sentence was a door that kept opening.
What was established in that courtroom: a conviction.
What was established in that courtroom: a death sentence.
What was established in that courtroom: the record.
The record says the jury convicted on August 5.
The record says the judge sentenced on September 26.
That is where the trial ended.
That is where the waiting began.
AND THE STORY STILL ISN'T OVER
Richard Allen Davis remains on death row at San Quentin State Prison.
His appeals have been ongoing for decades.
The record does not specify the current status of those appeals.
Not the outcome, not the next step, not a date.
That would require a document that is not here.
The case did not end with the sentence.
It changed the law in California.
The case led to the passage of "Three Strikes" legislation.
It led to the creation of the Amber Alert system for missing children.
Marc Klaas founded the KlaasKids Foundation.
It is dedicated to child safety and missing children's issues.
Eve Nichol has largely stayed out of the public eye.
She was in another part of the house that night.
She did not hear the intrusion.
Polly's death remains a touchstone in the history of American child abduction cases.
It is a reference point.
It is a warning.
The two friends freed themselves.
They alerted Eve Nichol.
That part of the story is over.
The rest is not.
Davis sits on death row.
The appeals continue.
The laws remain.
The foundation works.
The mother stays quiet.
The case stays open in the public memory.
It is unfinished.
It is also settled.
The sentence was handed down on September 26.
The waiting began then.
It has not ended.
Advertisement
You may also like
A boat bought days before a missing wife — the timeline detectives couldn't shake
He reported her missing on December 24, 2002. Laci Peterson was eight months pregnant, and Scott Peterson told police she had vanished from their…
The rear axle that cracked the Oklahoma City bombing case open
The rear axle sat in a crater of broken glass and concrete, blocks from where the Murrah Building's north face used to be. At…
The fishing alibi, the affair, and the phone calls that unraveled Scott Peterson's story
December 24, 2002. Laci Peterson, 27 and eight months pregnant, was reported missing from her Modesto, California home. Her husband, Scott Peterson, told police…
The $50,000 ransom note that led to a gas station and a carpenter's arrest
In September 1934, a gold certificate from the $50,000 ransom surfaced at a gas station. The attendant wrote down the license plate of the…
The night Sharon Tate's housekeeper found the phone line cut — before the bodies were discovered
She found it before anyone knew to look. On the night of August 9, 1969, the housekeeper at 10050 Cielo Drive discovered the phone…
The Christmas Eve disappearance that left a family waiting 111 days for answers
The Christmas Eve call came at 5:45 p.m. Scott Peterson told police his wife was missing. Laci Peterson, 27 and eight months pregnant, had…